Same Difference…

All ad agencies are essentially the same. That’s probably going to see me vilified by the end of the day – particularly by my colleagues who work at ad agencies. But before you reach for the pitchforks and flaming torches, just hear me out.

All ad agencies are essentially the same. I mean, we all do the same thing – just to varying degrees of success and competence. So why should you choose one agency over another?

If you answered “Because agency X has won more awards than agency Y”, then you, my fine feather-headed friend, are the reason there are sayings about fools and their money. Choosing an agency based on the number of awards they’ve won is like choosing a cardiac surgeon based on his car.

The thing that sets one agency apart from the rest is the way they treat you (and your brand) as a client. I’m not talking about the sushi-lunches and the parties. I’m talking about the way your agency works for your brand.

Does your agency create effective solutions to your business problems? Are they proactive (“We found this and thought it might work for you…”) or reactive (“What do you want us to do now ?”)? And have you ever met the writers/designers that work on your brand? You should. It’s these guys and not the suits-and-tie folks who take you on sushi-lunches, who are working for you.

By the way, the TANSTAAFL principle applies like no other in the advertising industry. Yes, you’re paying for those sushi-lunches. You just don’t know it.

Finally, when you’re choosing an agency, don’t ask for their credentials or their portfolio. Ask for a client list – past and present. And then go and interview those clients (especially those that don’t work with the agency) about their relationships with the agency. This will give you a better idea about the agency you’re considering employing.

OK, then..flaming torches at the ready? You may fire when ready.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Same Difference…

  1. Choosing an agency based on the number of awards they’ve won is like choosing a cardiac surgeon based on the number of awards he’s won for heart surgeries ?

    Choosing an agency based on their car’s is like choosing a cardiac surgeon based on his car.

    fixed ?

    • LOL. Not really. It depends on the criteria for the awards and who awarded them. As for the cars, that’s also no real indication. Cars may be low-cost by choice…or expensive for show.

      Awards (for the most part) and cars are no indication of competency – only of how much shiny stuff those people have.

  2. “Because agency X has won more awards than agency Y”

    agency X sounds better, i would go with them (depending of course what kind of cars they drive)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s